State of Wisconsin Department of Children and Families v. Terrell, No. 21-3059 (7th Cir. 2022)

Annotate this Case

After filing for bankruptcy, the Terrells proposed a plan that classified about $30,000 they owed to Wisconsin as a “priority debt,” 11 U.S.C. 507(a)(1)(B) based on an overpayment of public assistance. The existence of a priority debt meant that the Chapter 13 plan had to continue for 60 months, after which unpaid debts would be discharged. After the plan was confirmed, the Seventh Circuit held that public assistance debts are not entitled to priority status, which raised the possibility of cutting the duration of the Terrell plan to 36 months and reducing the amount they paid. The bankruptcy court eventually amended the plan accordingly.

The Seventh Circuit reversed, noting that the Terrells waited almost two years after the confirmation of their plan to seek a modification. A bankruptcy court needs authority from a statute, a rule, or the litigants’ consent to modify a confirmed plan. The Terrells acted too late to use Rule 60(b), the best and possibly the only source of authority for the relief they sought.

Download PDF

In the United States Court of Appeals For the Seventh Circuit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

Primary Holding

Bankruptcy court lacked authority to modify a Chapter 13 plan almost two years after its confirmation.

Disclaimer: Justia Annotations is a forum for attorneys to summarize, comment on, and analyze case law published on our site. Justia makes no guarantees or warranties that the annotations are accurate or reflect the current state of law, and no annotation is intended to be, nor should it be construed as, legal advice. Contacting Justia or any attorney through this site, via web form, email, or otherwise, does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Some case metadata and case summaries were written with the help of AI, which can produce inaccuracies. You should read the full case before relying on it for legal research purposes.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.